The peer reviews are graded together, out of 10 points
[10]. Excellent. One or more insightful comments, in an otherwise careful pair of reviews. The grader will make preliminary notes on each project before reading the peer reviews—one way to secure an excellent review grade is to write a report that is useful to the grader for extending, clarifying, or correcting their review notes.
[9]. Careful reviews, correctly identifying several strengths and weaknesses.
[8]. Thoughtful comments, but with limitations. Perhaps inadequate attention was paid to technical detail. Less commonly, too much attention is given to technical detail at the expense of a broader view.
[7]. Satisfactory, but superficial. Missing multiple issues.
[0-6]. Work not carried out to Masters level.